🇪🇺Europe

Ciracle Pore Tightening Toner for oily skin

Average

  • SuperiorOily Skin Fit
  • HighEffectiveness
  • ConcerningSafety

Works for oily skin; other products fit it better.

This fit is calculated for the concerns frequently associated with oily skin: shine, enlarged pores, blackheads, and blemishes. For scores and recommendations based on your full skin profile, including your 12D face scan results and any goals or preferences you have, please use the Lovi app.

Updated How the Fit score works

Lovi Assistant explains

  • Offers moderate benefits for oily shine and pores due to the presence of alcohol and menthol derivatives that help control oil and tighten pores, though these ingredients may also cause irritation and dryness for your oily skin.
  • The inclusion of witch hazel leaf extract and menthol lactate provides astringent and cooling effects, which are beneficial for seboregulation and pore tightening.

How to apply

  • Use your toner PM to control oily shine and start 3 times a week before working up to daily use.
  • Apply the toner after cleansing and before your moisturizer to prep your skin.
  • Gently press 2-3 drops of the toner into your skin and let it absorb fully.
  • Apply the toner on clean, dry skin to ensure the best results for your oily type.
  • Avoid the eye area and do a patch test before your first use.

People Say

★3.9Overall rating based on 100+ reviews

Based on limited data, users with oily and acne-prone skin find this toner effective for controlling sebum and providing a refreshing sensation. Many report a temporary tightening effect on pores and smoother skin texture. However, some users note the high alcohol content can be drying and the price may not be justified by the results.

Highlights

  • Quick absorption Mostly Mentioned
    • “Quickly absorbed without stickiness”
    • “great absorbance”
    • “lightweight and watery”
  • Effective oil control Often Mentioned
    • “Face has never been so oil-free”
    • “controls excessive sebum”
    • “blot my face less”
  • Strong alcohol scent Often Mentioned
    • “Slight alcohol-like scent”
    • “smells like mouthwash”
    • “high alcohol content”
  • Pore tightening Sometimes Noted
    • “Elastically tightening pores”
    • “feel pores shrinking”
    • “tightens my pores”
  • Refreshing sensation Sometimes Noted
    • “Cooling sensation”
    • “refreshing and cooling”
    • “leaves skin feeling clean”
  • Price vs value Sometimes Noted
    • “over-priced”
    • “results aren't remarkable enough”
  • Limited availability Rarely Noted
    • “Trickier to get your hands on”
    • “docking points for availability”
    • “hard to find”
  • Packaging issues Rarely Noted
    • “Spilled all inside packaging”
    • “pump had slightly come off”

Sources: lovi.care, amazon.com, yesstyle.com, jolse.com, femaledaily.com, skinsli.com, and more

Questions and answers

How well does Ciracle Pore Tightening Toner work for oily skin?

This toner offers moderate benefits for oily shine and pores, but the alcohol and menthol derivatives may also cause irritation and dryness for your oily skin. A toner for oily skin needs ingredients that control oil and hydrate safely without the risk of irritation, along with pore-minimizing and texture-enhancing components.

Which ingredients make this toner a good fit for oily skin?

Witch hazel leaf extract, camellia sinensis leaf water, and menthyl lactate make this toner a fit for oily skin by helping control shine and tighten pores with cooling and astringent effects. Because alcohol and menthol derivatives may cause dryness and irritation, a toner for this skin needs ingredients that safely manage oil and improve texture without irritation, along with hydrating components and oil-regulating nutrients like niacin.

What does Witch Hazel Leaf Extract do for oily skin?

Witch hazel leaf extract helps calm oily skin and keeps excess shine under control. It is unlikely to cause irritation and may protect against redness and everyday environmental stress.

Journal of Cosmetic Dermatology, 2019Molecules, 2025

What does Green Tea Water do for oily skin?

Green tea water helps lower oil and shine on oily skin while keeping it hydrated. Regular use is unlikely to irritate and may calm redness, making it a good fit for skin that gets greasy easily.

Journal of Cosmetic Dermatology, 2023Bosnian Journal of Basic Medical Sciences, 2010

Where does it go in a skincare routine for oily skin?

This toner goes in the evening routine right after cleansing. Oily skin works best with alcohol-free options and calming plant extracts that control shine without causing dryness and irritation.

Can I use this toner with retinol, and in what order?

You can use this toner in your routine, but apply it with caution since its alcohol and menthol derivatives may cause dryness and irritation alongside retinol. To help keep your skin comfortable, oily skin needs a soothing toner with hydrating and barrier-restoring ingredients like ceramides or soothing plant extracts instead.

How often should I use it?

This toner can be used in your evening routine, but because it contains alcohol and menthol derivatives that may cause irritation and dryness for oily skin, you should start using it just once a week to see how your skin reacts. A product for oily skin like this needs soothing ingredients and gentle oil control that won't strip your skin.

Can this toner clog pores, cause breakouts or purging for oily skin?

This toner is unlikely to clog pores or cause breakouts because it has ingredients that help control oil and tighten pores, though alcohol and menthol derivatives may cause dryness and irritation for your oily skin. Products of this type need soothing ingredients like green tea water and allantoin to keep your skin calm and balanced.

Is it fragrance-free and alcohol-free?

It has no fragrance and contains drying alcohol (alcohol).

What the research says

  • A Hamamelis virginiana leaf extract increased LOXL1 expression twofold, decreased elafin synthesis, restored functional elastic fibers, reduced nonfunctional elastin aggregates, decreased wrinkles, and improved skin firmness.

    Journal of Cosmetic Science, 2018
  • Hamamelis bark proanthocyanidins strongly increased the proliferation of cultured human keratinocytes and reduced transepidermal water loss and erythema formation in SLS-irritated skin, whereas the polysaccharide fraction had no effect.

    Phytochemistry, 2001
  • Hamamelis virginiana bark extract inhibited Cutibacterium acnes-induced IL-6 release and TNF-α-induced IL-8 release in human keratinocytes without showing antibacterial or antibiofilm activities.

    Antioxidants, 2022
  • Topically formulated tea polyphenols show some benefit in reducing sebum secretion and treating acne vulgaris compared to baseline or control.

    Antioxidants, 2016
  • Topical application of tannase-converted green tea extract (TGE) significantly improved skin wrinkle indices and self-assessed wrinkle reduction compared to normal green tea extract (NGE) in human subjects over 8 weeks.

    Journal of Cosmetic Dermatology, 2013
  • An anti-acne hydrogel containing Aloe barbadensis, Garcinia mangostana, and Camellia sinensis extracts showed superior antiacne and antiblotch activities compared to 1% clindamycin gel in sixty subjects with mild-moderate acne.

    Clinical, Cosmetic and Investigational Dermatology, 2019
  • The ThriveCo Bumps Eraser Kit increased skin hydration by 131.75%, reduced redness by 69.30%, decreased pigmentation by 35.77%, dropped itchiness by 92.63%, improved smoothness by 55.00%, reduced roughness by 148.54%, and decreased scaliness by 87.09% without adverse effects.

    Cureus, 2025
  • The combination of allantoin, bisabolol, D-panthenol and dipotassium glycyrrhizinate reduces UVB-induced PGE2, inflammatory cytokines, and mitochondrial superoxide in human epidermal keratinocytes.

    International Journal of Cosmetic Science, 2024
  • Tetracaine gel containing both 5% menthol and 70% ethanol provided significantly enhanced skin permeation, analgesia, and lower verbal pain scores compared to other tetracaine gels or EMLA cream in mice and human volunteers.

    European Journal of Pharmaceutics and Biopharmaceutics, 2008
  • Cooling skin temperature or applying topical menthol reduced histamine-induced itch intensity and flare diameters in healthy male volunteers.

    Neuroscience Letters, 1995
  • Topical application of a methyl salicylate gel with turpentine essence, camphor, and menthol achieved skin penetration and significantly reduced pro-inflammatory gene expression compared to untreated controls in human skin explants.

    Farmaceuticos Comunitarios, 2024
  • Combining 755 nm alexandrite laser with topical licorice gel significantly reduces terminal hair counts compared to alexandrite laser with placebo in women with idiopathic hirsutism.

    Evidence-based Complementary and Alternative Medicine, 2015
  • Licochalcone A activated Nrf2 signaling, elevated cytoprotective enzymes, increased the reduced-to-oxidized glutathione ratio, and decreased reactive oxygen species in human fibroblasts and neutrophils, while a LicA-rich licorice extract lowered UVA-induced oxidative processes in vivo.

    Experimental Dermatology, 2015
  • Mesoporous silica nanoparticles entrapping licorice polysaccharide and coated with polydopamine showed 76% entrapment efficiency, 89% in vitro release at pH 5, increased sebocytes' cellular uptake, and mediated inflammatory response by inhibiting pro-inflammatory cytokines and regulating anti-inflammatory cytokines.

    Carbohydrate Polymers, 2024

Why other products fit oily skin better

  • Menthol derivatives in this product

    Topical menthol induced significant pain, cold sensations, punctate and cold hyperalgesia, and increased cutaneous perfusion in 10 subjects compared to ethanol control, acting as a human model for cold pain by sensitizing peripheral cold C nociceptors and activating cold-specific A delta fibres.

    Brain, 2004
  • Menthol derivatives in this product

    Topical menthol strongly activates and sensitizes Type 2 C fibres to cooling, which also respond to heating and continue to discharge down to 0 degrees C, potentially accounting for paradoxical thermal sensations and neuropathic pain.

    The Journal of Physiology, 2009

Ingredients

Water, Alcohol, Camellia Sinensis Leaf Water, Pentylene Glycol, Peg-60 Hydrogenated Castor Oil, Butylene Glycol, Bis-Peg-18 Methyl Ether Dimethyl Silane, Methylparaben, Allantoin, Ethyl Hexanediol, Dipotassium Glycyrrhizate, Phenoxyethanol, Witch Hazel Leaf Extract, Mentha Haplocalix Extract, Menthyl Lactate, Citric Acid

Behind this fit score

Lovi calculates every fit score from the full ingredient list with brand-independent rules our dermatologists and cosmetic chemists build and review, and personalizes every pick with AI trained on the real results of millions of users. Lovi trains its fit score models on a proprietary dataset built from more than 10,000 expert-labeled products and more than 100,000 simulated examples, following an internally consistent methodology presented at Cosmoprof, AMWC, and Skin of Color Update.

How does it fit your skin?

Scan your face, then any product.

How does it fit your skin?

Scan your face, then any product: Lovi shows how well it fits you and what fits even better.